下载App
旅行
账户
Tripadvisor用户
An Important History That Could Open Up Much More
Musée Acadien Du Québec的点评
点评：The museum was worth seeing because it appears to be the only one devoted to the history of the Acadians, their violent displacement, and their dispersal throughout the western hemisphere. In the mid-18th century, during what is known as the Great Derangement or Expulsion of Acadians, French inhabitants of Acadia were forcibly and sometimes violently deported from the region, which had come under the control of Great Britain. The Acadians dispersed to Europe and other sites in the Americas, notably Louisiana, where “Acadian” became “Cajun.”
This history is important, but the museum sticks fairly close to this central injustice without adding much contextualization or analysis. Do diasporic Acadians share a culture as well as a traumatic history? How is Acadian heritage/identity understood among different Acadian communities, including the well-known Cajun community? In what sense are Acadians an ethnicity (as the museum indicates)? Other than the general friendliness indicated, what were relations like between the Acadians and the Mi’kmaq (and could this be contextualized in relation to French vs British imperial attitudes and practices)? What made the Acadians focus on farming rather than fishing? What would it mean to consider the Great Derangement in relation to other British imperial displacements and cultural erasures?
Some of the physical exhibits were less engaging than they could have been with a little more thought about how to frame their significance.
The museum is housed in the farmstead of a former dairy, and there’s an interesting exhibit about the family who owned it in the context of Canadian/Quebecois/Acadian women’s history. The staff is extremely helpful.
This history is important, but the museum sticks fairly close to this central injustice without adding much contextualization or analysis. Do diasporic Acadians share a culture as well as a traumatic history? How is Acadian heritage/identity understood among different Acadian communities, including the well-known Cajun community? In what sense are Acadians an ethnicity (as the museum indicates)? Other than the general friendliness indicated, what were relations like between the Acadians and the Mi’kmaq (and could this be contextualized in relation to French vs British imperial attitudes and practices)? What made the Acadians focus on farming rather than fishing? What would it mean to consider the Great Derangement in relation to other British imperial displacements and cultural erasures?
Some of the physical exhibits were less engaging than they could have been with a little more thought about how to frame their significance.
The museum is housed in the farmstead of a former dairy, and there’s an interesting exhibit about the family who owned it in the context of Canadian/Quebecois/Acadian women’s history. The staff is extremely helpful.
翻译：这座博物馆值得一看，因为它似乎是唯一一家致力于展现阿卡迪亚人历史的博物馆，展现了他们暴力流离失所以及在西半球的流散历程。18世纪中叶，在所谓的“阿卡迪亚人大错乱”或“驱逐”时期，居住在阿卡迪亚的法国居民被强行驱逐出该地区，有时甚至遭到暴力驱逐，该地区当时已被英国控制。阿卡迪亚人流散到欧洲和美洲其他地区，尤其是路易斯安那州，“阿卡迪亚人”在这里变成了“卡津人”。
这段历史很重要，但博物馆却只是贴近这一核心的不公，没有添加太多的背景或分析。流散的阿卡迪亚人是否拥有共同的文化以及一段痛苦的历史？不同的阿卡迪亚人社群，包括著名的卡津人社群，是如何理解阿卡迪亚人的传统/身份的？在何种意义上，阿卡迪亚人是一个民族（正如博物馆所表明的那样）？除了普遍表现出的友好关系之外，阿卡迪亚人和米克马克人之间的关系如何（这是否可以与法国和英国帝国主义的态度和做法联系起来）？是什么让阿卡迪亚人专注于农业而不是渔业？将“大错乱”与其他英国帝国主义的迁移和文化抹杀联系起来，意味着什么？
一些实体展品如果能多加思考如何构建其意义，吸引力可能会有所减弱。
博物馆坐落在一座前奶牛场的农场里，其中有一个关于农场主家庭的有趣展览，以加拿大/魁北克/阿卡迪亚女性的历史为背景。工作人员非常乐于助人。
这段历史很重要，但博物馆却只是贴近这一核心的不公，没有添加太多的背景或分析。流散的阿卡迪亚人是否拥有共同的文化以及一段痛苦的历史？不同的阿卡迪亚人社群，包括著名的卡津人社群，是如何理解阿卡迪亚人的传统/身份的？在何种意义上，阿卡迪亚人是一个民族（正如博物馆所表明的那样）？除了普遍表现出的友好关系之外，阿卡迪亚人和米克马克人之间的关系如何（这是否可以与法国和英国帝国主义的态度和做法联系起来）？是什么让阿卡迪亚人专注于农业而不是渔业？将“大错乱”与其他英国帝国主义的迁移和文化抹杀联系起来，意味着什么？
一些实体展品如果能多加思考如何构建其意义，吸引力可能会有所减弱。
博物馆坐落在一座前奶牛场的农场里，其中有一个关于农场主家庭的有趣展览，以加拿大/魁北克/阿卡迪亚女性的历史为背景。工作人员非常乐于助人。
© 2025 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
