下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
Tripadvisor用户
Disappointed at Monkey Mia: A Call for Better Wildlife Welfare and Visitor Fairness
RAC Monkey Mia Dolphin Resort的点评
点评：Friday 16th October - We set off early for Monkey Mia, hoping to enjoy the much-publicised dolphin experience. Unfortunately, the experience was extremely disappointing and, in my opinion, poor value for money.
While I fully appreciate that dolphins are wild animals and their appearance can never be guaranteed, my concern is with the environment in which visitors are expected to view them. From my own experience, dolphins can be remarkably interactive with humans when they feel safe and are approached in a respectful, controlled environment.
Monkey Mia promotes the presence of approximately 200–300 dolphins in the surrounding area, with a small, carefully managed group of resident adult females regularly visiting the shoreline for regulated feeding sessions. However, given the conditions we witnessed, it was hardly surprising that the dolphins did not appear.
Boats were moving back and forth open bay and feeding area, while dogs could be heard barking and growling along the jetty. These disturbances hardly seem conducive to creating a calm and safe environment for wildlife. Dolphins are intelligent animals, and it is unrealistic to expect them to approach the shoreline when they may perceive potential risks, particularly when there is an abundance of natural food available in the bay.
I believe Monkey Mia should give greater consideration to the conditions in which these encounters take place and introduce a fairer policy for visitors when no dolphins appear.
While I understand that wildlife encounters cannot be guaranteed, visitors are paying for the opportunity to experience something special, and there should be greater accountability when that experience does not eventuate.
Unfortunately, I left feeling that the experience was more about the commercial attraction than the welfare and natural behaviour of the dolphins.
My advice to anyone planning a trip to Western Australia specifically to see dolphins is to do your research before spending your money at Monkey Mia. Perhaps consider Tin Can Bay in Queensland as an alternative for a dolphin encounter.
A very disappointing experience that fell well short of expectations.
While I fully appreciate that dolphins are wild animals and their appearance can never be guaranteed, my concern is with the environment in which visitors are expected to view them. From my own experience, dolphins can be remarkably interactive with humans when they feel safe and are approached in a respectful, controlled environment.
Monkey Mia promotes the presence of approximately 200–300 dolphins in the surrounding area, with a small, carefully managed group of resident adult females regularly visiting the shoreline for regulated feeding sessions. However, given the conditions we witnessed, it was hardly surprising that the dolphins did not appear.
Boats were moving back and forth open bay and feeding area, while dogs could be heard barking and growling along the jetty. These disturbances hardly seem conducive to creating a calm and safe environment for wildlife. Dolphins are intelligent animals, and it is unrealistic to expect them to approach the shoreline when they may perceive potential risks, particularly when there is an abundance of natural food available in the bay.
I believe Monkey Mia should give greater consideration to the conditions in which these encounters take place and introduce a fairer policy for visitors when no dolphins appear.
While I understand that wildlife encounters cannot be guaranteed, visitors are paying for the opportunity to experience something special, and there should be greater accountability when that experience does not eventuate.
Unfortunately, I left feeling that the experience was more about the commercial attraction than the welfare and natural behaviour of the dolphins.
My advice to anyone planning a trip to Western Australia specifically to see dolphins is to do your research before spending your money at Monkey Mia. Perhaps consider Tin Can Bay in Queensland as an alternative for a dolphin encounter.
A very disappointing experience that fell well short of expectations.
翻译：10月16日星期五——我们清晨出发前往 Monkey Mia，希望能体验一下广为宣传的赏海豚活动。遗憾的是，这次体验极其令人失望，在我看来性价比也很低。
我完全理解海豚是野生动物，它们的出现并非必然，但我所担忧的是游客们观赏海豚的环境。以我个人的经历来看……当感到安全且处于一个受尊重且受控的环境中时，海豚会表现出极强的与人类互动的意愿。
在猴米亚地区，周边水域大约有200至300只海豚出没。其中有一小群经过精心管理的成年雌性海豚，会定期到岸边接受有管控的喂食。不过，鉴于我们当时所见到的情况，这些海豚并未出现也就不足为奇了。船只在海湾及觅食区来回穿梭，码头上还能听到狗吠声和咆哮声。这些干扰因素显然无助于为野生动物营造一个平静且安全的环境。海豚是非常聪明的动物，当它们察觉到可能存在的风险时，指望它们靠近岸边是不现实的——尤其是当海湾中有大量天然食物可供食用的时候。我认为猴子米亚应当更仔细地考量这些互动发生的条件，并在没有海豚出现时为游客制定更为公平的政策。
虽然我理解无法保证一定能看到野生动物，但游客们付费就是为了获得一次特别的体验；当这种体验未能实现时，相关方面理应承担更多责任。
遗憾的是。离开时我觉得，这次体验更多体现的是商业吸引力，而非海豚的福利或其自然行为习性。
对于那些专程前往西澳大利亚观赏海豚的游客，我的建议是在花钱去 Monkey Mia 之前先做些调查研究。或许可以考虑将昆士兰州的 Tin Can Bay作为观赏海豚的替代地点。
这是一次极其令人失望的体验，完全没能达到预期。
我完全理解海豚是野生动物，它们的出现并非必然，但我所担忧的是游客们观赏海豚的环境。以我个人的经历来看……当感到安全且处于一个受尊重且受控的环境中时，海豚会表现出极强的与人类互动的意愿。
在猴米亚地区，周边水域大约有200至300只海豚出没。其中有一小群经过精心管理的成年雌性海豚，会定期到岸边接受有管控的喂食。不过，鉴于我们当时所见到的情况，这些海豚并未出现也就不足为奇了。船只在海湾及觅食区来回穿梭，码头上还能听到狗吠声和咆哮声。这些干扰因素显然无助于为野生动物营造一个平静且安全的环境。海豚是非常聪明的动物，当它们察觉到可能存在的风险时，指望它们靠近岸边是不现实的——尤其是当海湾中有大量天然食物可供食用的时候。我认为猴子米亚应当更仔细地考量这些互动发生的条件，并在没有海豚出现时为游客制定更为公平的政策。
虽然我理解无法保证一定能看到野生动物，但游客们付费就是为了获得一次特别的体验；当这种体验未能实现时，相关方面理应承担更多责任。
遗憾的是。离开时我觉得，这次体验更多体现的是商业吸引力，而非海豚的福利或其自然行为习性。
对于那些专程前往西澳大利亚观赏海豚的游客，我的建议是在花钱去 Monkey Mia 之前先做些调查研究。或许可以考虑将昆士兰州的 Tin Can Bay作为观赏海豚的替代地点。
这是一次极其令人失望的体验，完全没能达到预期。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
