下载App
旅行
账户
railway_chap
Didn’t like it at all
Museum of Making at Derby Silk Mill的点评
点评：I don’t often give bad reviews, but wasn’t impressed by this museum at all. Objects poorly displayed with no organisation, context, apparent purpose or explanation. Large empty spaces and woke hand ringing about how bad the British Empire was at every opportunity. I thought this was supposed to celebrate British innovation and tell the story of “making” in Derby.
There is virtually nothing about the listed building, silk making or why it’s an important world heritage site.
The ground floor is largely emptied out as a presumably more lucrative function space. What exhibits there are seem to be pretty much in use as wall paper to create “ambiance”.
The first floor has the majority of the displays, but seems disorganised and again such exhibits as there are have been poorly displayed.
The second floor is a jumble of stuff on pallets. They are completely unlabelled and organised, like a 10 year old would, by colour and material. How this is supposed to stimulate the next generation of engineers and entrepreneurs I can’t say. Some of these exhibits were war dead rolls of honour from factories and the like. Seems somewhat inappropriate having these stacked on pallets with miscellaneous workshop ephemera.
The best part of the museum is the excellent model railway. This was the only element to save it from being a one star.
The top floor has been largely flogged off as rented work space, apart from a temporary exhibition space that was not open and a shop selling locally made nick-nacks. Oh and not to forget the “viewing area” which you can only reach by going back down and up again. I really suggest this isn’t worth the effort as the only view was of a dystopian wasteland being graffitied in broad daylight by two youths.
All in all I think this is a lost opportunity. At least it’s free, but I’d be happy to pay an entrance charge for a proper industrial museum.
There is virtually nothing about the listed building, silk making or why it’s an important world heritage site.
The ground floor is largely emptied out as a presumably more lucrative function space. What exhibits there are seem to be pretty much in use as wall paper to create “ambiance”.
The first floor has the majority of the displays, but seems disorganised and again such exhibits as there are have been poorly displayed.
The second floor is a jumble of stuff on pallets. They are completely unlabelled and organised, like a 10 year old would, by colour and material. How this is supposed to stimulate the next generation of engineers and entrepreneurs I can’t say. Some of these exhibits were war dead rolls of honour from factories and the like. Seems somewhat inappropriate having these stacked on pallets with miscellaneous workshop ephemera.
The best part of the museum is the excellent model railway. This was the only element to save it from being a one star.
The top floor has been largely flogged off as rented work space, apart from a temporary exhibition space that was not open and a shop selling locally made nick-nacks. Oh and not to forget the “viewing area” which you can only reach by going back down and up again. I really suggest this isn’t worth the effort as the only view was of a dystopian wasteland being graffitied in broad daylight by two youths.
All in all I think this is a lost opportunity. At least it’s free, but I’d be happy to pay an entrance charge for a proper industrial museum.
翻译：我很少给差评，但这家博物馆却让我印象非常深刻。展品陈列简陋，缺乏条理，缺乏背景信息，也缺乏明确的用途和解释。空荡荡的大空间里，到处都是人手忙脚乱地敲打着大英帝国的烂摊子。我以为这里是为了庆祝英国的创新，讲述德比的“制造”故事。
几乎没有任何关于这座受保护建筑、丝绸制造或它为何成为重要世界遗产的介绍。
一楼大部分被空置，用作一个可能更有利可图的功能空间。展品似乎只是用来营造“氛围”的墙纸。
一楼的大部分展品都陈列在一楼，但摆放得比较杂乱，而且这些展品的摆放也很差。
二楼的托盘上堆满了杂乱的东西。它们完全没有标签，而且像一个10岁小孩那样按颜色和材质摆放。我不知道这究竟能如何激励下一代工程师和企业家。有些展品是工厂之类的战死者荣誉榜。把它们和各种车间纪念品堆放在托盘上，似乎有些不妥。
博物馆最棒的部分是精美的模型铁路。这是唯一让它免于一星评价的因素。
除了一个尚未开放的临时展览空间和一家出售当地小饰品的商店外，顶层大部分都被用作出租的工作空间。哦，别忘了还有一个“观景区”，你只能走下去再上去才能到达。我真心觉得这不值得，因为唯一的景观就是两个年轻人在光天化日之下在一片反乌托邦的荒地上涂鸦。
总而言之，我觉得这是一个错失的机会。至少它是免费的，但我很乐意为一个真正的工业博物馆支付门票费。
几乎没有任何关于这座受保护建筑、丝绸制造或它为何成为重要世界遗产的介绍。
一楼大部分被空置，用作一个可能更有利可图的功能空间。展品似乎只是用来营造“氛围”的墙纸。
一楼的大部分展品都陈列在一楼，但摆放得比较杂乱，而且这些展品的摆放也很差。
二楼的托盘上堆满了杂乱的东西。它们完全没有标签，而且像一个10岁小孩那样按颜色和材质摆放。我不知道这究竟能如何激励下一代工程师和企业家。有些展品是工厂之类的战死者荣誉榜。把它们和各种车间纪念品堆放在托盘上，似乎有些不妥。
博物馆最棒的部分是精美的模型铁路。这是唯一让它免于一星评价的因素。
除了一个尚未开放的临时展览空间和一家出售当地小饰品的商店外，顶层大部分都被用作出租的工作空间。哦，别忘了还有一个“观景区”，你只能走下去再上去才能到达。我真心觉得这不值得，因为唯一的景观就是两个年轻人在光天化日之下在一片反乌托邦的荒地上涂鸦。
总而言之，我觉得这是一个错失的机会。至少它是免费的，但我很乐意为一个真正的工业博物馆支付门票费。
© 2025 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
